505 S Bay Blvd, photo 1
Active
1 / 34

Overview

5 bd5 ba3,202 sqft2 car garageSingle Family
TypeSingle Family
HOANone listed
Built2014
Lot7,301 sqft
Living area3,202 sqft
Price / sqft$859
Garage2 car

Ask anything about this home

Pricing, comps, HOA, the neighborhood. Answers before you fill out anything.

About this home

Ceiling Fans(s)Crown MoldingEat-in KitchenElevatorL DiningThermostatWalk-in Closet(s)Window Treatments

505 S Bay Blvd is a 2014-built home in Wells Bay Harbor Sec A Rep, Anna Maria. Inside you'll find 5 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, and 3,202 square feet of living space. Listed at $2,750,000 (about $859/sqft), 297 days on market. Flood zone AE - confirm flood insurance requirements with your lender.

From the listing

Grandfathered to accommodate up to 12 guests—a rare and increasingly valuable advantage on Anna Maria Island—505 S Bay Boulevard offers an exceptional opportunity for investors seeking one of the island's highest-performing vacation rental properties. Unlike many homes subject to today's stricter occupancy regulations, this property retains its coveted higher occupancy allowance, creating significantly greater rental flexibility and income potential. The results speak for themselves: the property has already generated more than $163,000 in gross rental income by the end of June and is currently projected to exceed $210,000 in gross rental revenue by year-end, making this an incredible opportunity to own a luxury waterfront home with proven, substantial income-producing performance. Let the island breeze guide you home to 505 S Bay Boulevard, a waterfront haven where the world slows down and coastal living feels like poetry. Tucked along the tranquil north end of Anna Maria Island, this elevated five-bedroom, five-bath home invites you to experience a lifestyle wrapped in beauty, comfort, and pure island magic. Step inside and discover more than 3,200 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, filled with natural light and framed by sweeping water views. The open-concept floor plan flows seamlessly, anchored by a gourmet kitchen featuring dual islands, high-end finishes, and a gas cooktop—perfect for everyday living and effortless entertaining. Multiple ensuite bedrooms, a versatile top-floor loft, and separate living areas provide privacy and flexibility for family, guests, or long-term stays. Four balconies extend the indoor living spaces outdoors, offering uninterrupted views of spectacular sunrises over the bay and peaceful evenings overlooking the water. Luxury amenities continue throughout the property, including a heated saltwater pool, private boat dock and lift on the canal, an eco-friendly rainwater cistern system, two tankless water heaters, an R38-rated metal roof with spray-foam insulated walls for exceptional energy efficiency, and a transferable 25-year termite warranty for added peace of mind. For boating enthusiasts, the home's 32 feet of saltwater canal frontage, deeded boat slip, and private lift provide direct access to the Intracoastal Waterway and the Gulf of Mexico. Durable coastal construction, impact-resistant features, and low-maintenance materials ensure lasting value while embracing the waterfront lifestyle. Beyond the home, Anna Maria Island offers one of Florida's most celebrated coastal experiences. A short stroll or bike ride leads to the charming boutiques, cafés, and galleries along Pine Avenue, while world-famous sugar-sand beaches and crystal-clear Gulf waters provide endless opportunities for boating, paddleboarding, fishing, shelling, and unforgettable sunsets. At 505 S Bay Boulevard, you're not simply purchasing a luxury waterfront residence—you're acquiring one of Anna Maria Island's rare investment opportunities, combining grandfathered high occupancy, exceptional proven rental performance, premier boating access, and the timeless island lifestyle that continues to make this one of Florida's most sought-after coastal destinations.

The essentials

Built
2014
Price / sqft
$859
On market
297 days
Annual tax
$35,732
Flood zone
AE
Lot
7,301 sqft
Type
Single Family Residence

At a glance

Single family
Built 2014
Waterfront
Canal - Saltwater
Private pool
Heated
2 car garage
Driveway
7,301 sqft lot
Lot size

Payment

Est. monthly payment
$18,695/mo
Down payment (20%)
$550,000
Property taxes
$2,978/mo
Rate assumed
6.8% · 30 yr
View full breakdown

Details

Type
Single Family Residence
Year Built
2014
Lot
7,301 sqft
Cooling
Central Air
Heating
Central, Electric
Parking
Driveway, Garage Door Opener, Ground Level, Off Street, On Street, Parking Pad, Garage
Pool
Gunite, Heated, In Ground, Salt Water
Waterfront
Canal - Saltwater
Days on Market
297
Ceiling Fans(s)
Crown Molding
Eat-in Kitchen
Elevator
L Dining
Thermostat
Walk-in Closet(s)
Window Treatments
Balcony
Lighting
Outdoor Shower
Rain Barrel/Cistern(s)
Rain Gutters
Sidewalk
Sprinkler Metered
Storage
Street Lights
Built-in Oven
Convection Oven
Cooktop
Dishwasher
Disposal
Dryer
Range
Range Hood
Refrigerator
Tankless Water Heater
Washer
Wine Refrigerator
Flood Zone AE
Annual Tax (2025)
$35,732
Parcel #
6935500006

Taxes reflect the most recent assessment in the MLS feed. Actual tax owed can vary, so confirm with the county property appraiser before closing.

Subdivision
Wells Bay Harbor Sec A Rep
County
Manatee
MLS Area
34216 - Anna Maria
Lot Size
7,301 sqft

Price history

Date
Event
Price
6/19/2026
Price change
Source: Stellar MLS #TB8456067
$2,750,000-8.3%
$859/sqft
-
Price change
Source: Stellar MLS #TB8456067
$2,999,000-6.1%
$937/sqft
12/19/2025
Listed for sale
Source: Stellar MLS #TB8456067
$3,195,000
$998/sqft

Neighborhood

505 S Bay Blvd
Anna Maria, FL, 34216 · 34216 - Anna Maria

Market insights

Offer Insights

Choose an offer strength

List price: $2,750,000
$2.59M – $2.75M
94.3% – 100% of listTops out right at the list price
80% of listList price
14 of the last 26 home closings in 34216 landed at this number or higher (54%). The median one sat 152 days before it went under contract, and this one is on day 297 after a $445,000 cut.

Sample: 26 closed home sales in 34216 over the last 8 months, Stellar MLS. A starting point, not a guarantee.

Talk through an offer with our team

Calculator

Est. monthly payment
$18,695/mo
Principal & interest$14,342
Property taxes$2,978
Insurance$1,375
Down payment20% · $550,000
Interest rate6.80%
Loan term

Not sure what you can afford?

Put in your household income and we will tell you where this payment sits.

Property taxes are this home's actual annual bill from the MLS, divided by twelve. Insurance estimated at 0.60%. Rate defaults to 6.8% on a 30-year fixed. Tap a pencil to use your own numbers. Estimates only, not a loan quote.

Quick answers.

Price

$2,750,000

$859 per sq ft

Beds and baths

5 beds, 5 baths

Size

3,202 sq ft

Time on market

297 days

Year built

2014

Monthly payment

About $18,695/mo

That is 20% down on a 30-year fixed at 6.8%, plus the home's $35,732 annual tax bill, insurance.

Flood zone

Zone AE

That is a high-risk designation, so a lender will normally require flood insurance. Confirm the current rate before you write an offer.

Offer

What should I offer?

Have another question?

Brokered byKELLER WILLIAMS SOUTH TAMPAListing agent: Brenda WadeListing data from Stellar MLS, MLS# TB8456067.

Keep exploring Florida

Pick up where you left off, or see what else is out there.